All Aliveness StoriesWork & relationships

Aliveness Stories / Work & relationships

Before you offer advice, ask this

A question that helps us understand whether someone wants to be heard, think through a decision or consider an idea.

The person opposite you has barely finished describing the problem when you see a possible solution. You know someone they could call, and a similar approach worked in another situation. While they are still explaining, you are already thinking about the next steps.

That impulse may come from care. It can still move the conversation somewhere the other person did not want to go. Perhaps they are trying to understand why the decision is difficult for them. Perhaps they need to say something aloud before they are ready to decide anything.

Imagine an independent designer telling a friend about a difficult client. The friend suggests raising the price, changing the contract or ending the relationship. Each idea might become relevant. But the designer is still trying to explain why they agreed to another round of work after promising themselves they would stop. They may need a little time to understand that before discussing the next email.

There is a question I want us to make room for in conversations at Alive Together: “Would you like me to listen, help you think it through, or share an idea?” It gives the person speaking a say in what happens next. They can also ask for something different.

If they want to be heard, we can let them finish without preparing a reply to every sentence. “What feels most difficult about it?” may help them explain a part of the situation we have not understood. Sometimes they need a pause. We can wait without treating that pause as a request for advice.

If they want help thinking, we can ask about the decision itself. In the designer's situation, that might mean asking what they have already promised the client and what they would like to change. Reflecting back what we think we have heard gives them a chance to correct us: “You want to finish the work you agreed to, and you are unsure how to respond to the new requests. Have I understood that?”

And if they want ideas, we can offer them with enough context to be useful. Something that worked with a long-standing client may be unsuitable for a first project. Asking what they have already tried can save them from having to explain why our first suggestion is not available. They still decide what to do.

Research offers a reason to take listening seriously. Guy Itzchakov and colleagues conducted five experiments involving actual and imagined conversations. Participants reported less momentary loneliness with high-quality listening after sharing or imagining sharing a past experience of social rejection. That specific finding does not establish that the question above improves business decisions, treats persistent loneliness or produces the same effect in a peer group. Itzchakov and colleagues, 2023, published online in 2022.

The opening question is my practical suggestion for making our intentions clearer. It is only useful if we are willing to follow the answer. Asking whether someone wants us to listen, then interrupting with the advice we had already prepared, leaves the conversation much where it was.

Our capacity matters too. If we have ten minutes before another commitment, we can say that at the start. If the person needs expertise we do not have, we can be honest about what we can offer. Caring about their situation does not require us to take responsibility for solving it.

The kind of support someone wants can change as they speak. After a few minutes, the designer might ask, “Could you help me work out how to reply?” We can check whether they want to try writing it themselves first or would find an example useful. The conversation has moved on, and now we know where our help is wanted.

Connection & creation

Make time for
one another.

I’m building Alive Together for people who want meaningful work and a good life with others.